Rewriting Your Assignments for Clarity (Without Losing Rigor)
-Cookie Redding, CPAD Faculty
How many times have you given an assignment, only to hear a flood of questions that make you wonder if you explained it at all?
It happens to all of us. We put a lot of thought into the goals and expectations of a project, but when students read the prompt, they focus on a completely different part. Sometimes they miss what matters most. Other times, they are overwhelmed by all the instructions and have no idea where to begin. Assignment prompts that feel clear to us as instructors can be experienced as vague, confusing, or inconsistent by students.
That is where rewriting your assignments with clarity in mind can make a big difference. And no, this does not mean watering anything down. You can hold onto complexity, challenge, and rigor while making your assignments easier to understand and explore.
What Do We Mean by Clarity?
Clarity is not about simplification for its own sake. It is about alignment. Clear assignments help students understand what they are doing, why they are doing it, and how they can approach the work. Clarity gives them a way in.
When instructions are unclear, students may make guesses, follow surface-level steps, or give up before starting. This is especially true in creative, visual, or studio-based courses, where the goals may not be explicitly stated or the outcomes may feel open-ended.
Clarity does not mean lowering your standards. It means inviting students into the challenge with the support and information they need to succeed.
Why Assignment Clarity Matters in Creative Classrooms
Creative courses often emphasize exploration, experimentation, and iteration. That is part of what makes them so rich. But that same openness can create uncertainty for students, especially when expectations are not clearly communicated.
Clear assignments help students:
-
Spend less time trying to decode what you meant
-
Focus more energy on the work itself
-
Take greater creative risks because they understand the foundation
-
Reflect more effectively on their process and learning
Instructors also benefit from clearer project descriptions. You can give better feedback, assess work more fairly, and spend less time repeating the same clarifications across emails and critiques.
Strategies for Rewriting Assignments with Clarity
Here are some ways to revise your assignments while keeping them rigorous, challenging, and open to creative interpretation.
1. Focus on the Why
Start by explaining the purpose of the assignment. What is the point of this project? What skill, habit, or concept is it meant to develop?
Example:
Instead of saying “Create an abstract composition using three colors,”
try “This project explores how color relationships affect visual energy and tension. You will be using only three colors to push contrast, harmony, and compositional balance.”
Knowing the why helps students invest more fully in the what.
2. Break It into Parts
If an assignment has multiple layers, use visual spacing, bullets, or headings to separate them. Reading blocks of text with several different goals or constraints buried inside can be overwhelming.
Structure can help without over-scripting. For example, separate sections might be:
-
Project Overview
-
Goals and Learning Outcomes
-
Requirements
-
Format and Materials
-
Timeline
-
Questions to Consider
This kind of formatting supports both visual and neurodiverse learners who may need more structure to stay oriented.
3. Define Success Without Dictating Results
Rather than listing every detail, describe what success might look like in a range of ways. This leaves space for creativity while giving students direction.
Example:
“Successful projects will show thoughtful use of layering, a clear visual point of emphasis, and a connection to your chosen concept. Projects should reflect both intention and experimentation.”
You are not prescribing the outcome, but you are signaling what qualities will be valued.
4. Provide Examples and Non-Examples
Whenever possible, share past work (with permission) or mock examples. You do not need a full demo. Even two or three images can clarify the tone or approach you are inviting.
Better still, pair an example with a reflection on why it worked and what could be improved. This helps students move beyond copying and into understanding.
If you do not have visuals yet, walk through a hypothetical version in class. What decisions would you make if you were completing the prompt?
5. Check for Jargon or Vague Language
Terms like “engaging,” “strong,” or “successful” sound good, but mean very little without context. Where possible, replace abstract language with specific, observable criteria.
Try reading your prompt aloud or having a colleague read it. Ask them to tell you what they think the assignment is asking. If their takeaway does not match your intent, revise for clarity.
What Clarity Does Not Mean
It is important to note what this kind of rewriting is not.
Clarity is not about oversimplifying.
Clarity is not about doing the thinking for students.
Clarity is not about removing ambiguity entirely.
The goal is not to reduce complexity, but to reveal the structure that supports it. A well-written assignment prompt helps students understand where they are headed, even if the path includes moments of confusion, experimentation, or revision.
Sample Revision: Before and After
Here is a quick example to show how a few small changes can create more clarity without removing challenge.
Before:
Design a poster based on a current event. Use principles of design to create an effective composition. Your poster should reflect your personal style and communicate a message clearly.
After:
Create an 11 x 17 poster that responds to a current event of your choice. You will use principles of contrast, alignment, and hierarchy to guide your design decisions. The poster should balance strong visuals with a clear message. Choose a topic that matters to you and take a stand visually.
Goals: Explore how design communicates meaning and persuasion. Develop skills in layout, messaging, and visual storytelling.
Requirements:
-
Size: 11 x 17 inches, portrait orientation
-
Include a headline and at least one supporting visual
-
Use at least two of the following: type contrast, grid alignment, image-text layering
-
Prepare to share a brief rationale during critique
Final Thoughts
Clarity does not make a course easier. It makes it more effective. When students understand what they are being asked to do and why it matters, they are more likely to dig into the work in a meaningful way.
Creative learning thrives when students feel supported enough to take risks. Clear assignment materials are one of the easiest ways to give that support without compromising the depth or ambition of your course.
If it has been a while since you looked at how your assignments are written, this is a great time to revisit. A few small changes might unlock more confident and curious engagement from your students.